Sunak ‘considering Braverman plan to defy human rights law’ to save Rwanda plan


Rishi Sunak is considering a plan to defy the UK’s Human Rights Act as part of his desperate push to get his Rwanda deportation flights off the ground.

It comes as the PM comes under growing pressure from Suella Braverman and the Tory right to flaunt international law by “disapplying” the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).

Mr Sunak is reportedly weighing up some elements of the hardline plan by Ms Braverman – whom he sacked earlier this week – to thwart fresh legal challenges to Rwanda flights.

The Tory leader is considering an emergency bill that would deem Rwanda a “safe country” and make clear this overrides the Human Rights Act, according to The Times.

A less contentious option is to try to designate Rwanda a “safe” country without any attempt to override human rights law, with the two possibilities said to be part of “live” discussions.

Mr Sunak’s two-pronged strategy to dealing with the Supreme Court ruling against the government is to announce an emergency law that he says will enable parliament to “unequivocally” declare Rwanda a safe destination for asylum seekers.

The PM will also publish an upgraded agreement with the country which is expected to attempt to address the court’s concerns around “refoulement” – the potential for refugees rejected by Rwanda to be sent back to the country they are fleeing.

But Ms Braverman has demanded Mr Sunak goes further – saying she “demands of the government an end to self-deception and spin.” She wrote: “Tinkering with a failed plan will not stop the boats.”

She said the UK’s domestic or international obligations – the Human Rights Act and ECHR – need to be made invalid using “notwithstanding clauses”.

Suella Braverman has accused Rishi Sunak of ‘tinkering’ with failed plan


Senior Tory MP Danny Kruger, co-founder of the increasingly influential New Conservatives group, demanded that Mr Sunak “change course or we will lose the general election”.

Writing in The Telegraph, the leading right-winger warned No 10 that failure to get the Rwanda flights going could lead to a “formal split” in the Conservatives and “splinter” the party forever.

“We need the Emergency Rwanda Bill to assert supremacy over all the laws and international treaties invoked by the Supreme Court,” Mr Kruger wrote.

“This is existential. If we get this wrong, our party won’t just face rejection at the ballot box, but we risk splintering our coalition forever.”

He said Mr Sunak’s response to the Supreme Court ruling “makes me worry that they are not prepared to cut through the thicket of international and domestic laws and protocols that undermine parliament’s sovereignty”.

But Mr Sunak is facing concerns over the dilemma from both sides of his party, with the leading One Nation Tory moderate Damian Green stressing the importance of observing the rule of law.

“It’s not just all our own laws passed by parliament, and all international treaties that we have signed, that Suella wants to sweep away,” Mr Green told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme – before comparing Ms Braverman to dictators.

“Conservatives believe in a democratic country run by the rule of law. And dictators, Xi and Putin, would prefer to have the state completely untrammelled by any law. And so, as a democrat I oppose it.”

Immigration minister Robert Jenrick said to support elements of Braverman plan

(PA Wire)

Immigration minister Robert Jenrick reportedly backs elements of Ms Braverman’s Rwanda plan in a “belt and braces” push to get the flights to take off.

The Home Office minister had joined Ms Braverman in previously submitting proposals to No 10 which included four of the five points she outlined this week, according to The Telegraph.

On Friday Mr Sunak denied “tinkering” with the Rwanda policy after his sacked former home secretary suggested his plan to save the scheme would fail without more radical measures.

Speaking to broadcasters, Mr Sunak insisted he will “work night and day” to ensure domestic courts cannot “systemically” block flights to the east African nation.

Mr Sunak declined to say whether he would call a general election if the upper chamber blocked the new law – instead insisting it was up to Labour to help it reach the statute books.

Meanwhile, Lord Sumption, a former Supreme Court judge, told the BBC the plan to use a law to declare Rwanda as safe was “profoundly discreditable”, “constitutionally really quite extraordinary”, and would “effectively overrule” a decision by the UK’s highest court.

A government source said the treaty with Rwanda would be published “shortly”, but perhaps not as soon as Monday, as reports earlier suggested.

The Independent has approached No 10 for comment and Mr Jenrick for comment.

Ukraine War 24

Ukraine War 24

Read Previous

Bombs, betrayal and burying loved ones: The plight of one Ukraine village illustrates the toll of Russia’s invasion

Read Next

UK Treasury chief signals tax cuts and a squeeze on welfare benefits are on the way